Skip to main content

GE's GeoSpring Hybrid electric water heater

2019-02-24 update: Wrote this back in 2014 and only got around to publishing it now after making some final edits.

After the final repairs listed here the hot water heater worked without issue until we moved a few years later. It felt, and still feels, like this was just one of those products that was launched with known issues and that it should have had some design changes. Instead they kept shipping the same design for a number of years inspite of knowing a number customers would have to deal with them. In this case the condensate pan was made of inappropriate material for the fitting attachment that was intended for use, and the condenser had a design or manufacturing flaw that caused a serious galvanic reaction.

It's too bad that so many people had a negative experience with this relatively new technology given how energy efficient heat-pumps can be.

- Chris


2013

We've had a string of issues with our new GE GeoSpring Hybrid water heater. Many reviews on Amazon mirror our experiences with this product. The idea of a heat pump water heater is great for energy savings but this particular model appears to be plagued by poor design and manufacturing.

GE GeoSpring Hybrid water heater
We purchased a new water header around January 2013 to replace the one that was probably installed when the house was built, some 15+ years ago. The old water heater was starting to leak around the bottom and was already several years beyond its rated life. I live in Massachusetts and there was a rebate for heat pump water heaters. These heat pump water heaters are also supposed to provide a significant cost savings as the heat pump is more efficient than heating with electricity alone.

With the $750 Massachusetts rebate for the heat pump water heater it was appealing to both pay less than a conventional water heater and to get a heater with a lower operating cost. We went with what appeared to be the best one we could find, the GE GeoSpring Hybrid.
Model and unit information placard

Sometime a few days after installation

I noticed there was liquid at the bottom of the heater. It was easy to find the source, there was a large crack in the condensation pan that catches the condensation that comes off of the heat exchanger in the upper red portion of the unit. The threaded portion of the pan that accepts the fitting had cracked, as if it was either too small, the fitting too large, or the fitting had bottomed out. In any case it wasn't something that could be easily repaired. We called GE and they sent a technician.

First GE repair

The GE repair person came and disassembled part of the system and replaced the pan. Installed a new pan and the fitting and all was well.

Can't recall exact details here...

At some point in here the unit started throwing FC errors. Reading online this indicated that the heat pump portion of the system was malfunctioning and GE was called.

Friday - July 18th 2013

A technician from GE came to repair/replace the unit after the FC error. He ended up replacing the evaporator, condensate pan, an array of sensors and wiring harness. After that he refilled the system with refrigerant, put everything back together and hooked everything back up.

The issue with the system was galvanic reaction of the metals used in the condenser. These resulted in corrosion that resulted in the leakage of all of the system's refrigerant. The refrigerant damaged the condensate pan (that poor pan....) which is why it had to be replaced.

That weekend I went down to look at things and noticed some water by where the drain pan connects to the pvc drain. After looking at it with a flashlight it was apparent that the pan had broken again, right at the threads where the drain screws in. This makes the third time it broke when the drain fitting was installed.

The pan was broken three times, twice by GE's own technicians and once by a plumber when the unit was installed.

Week of July 21st, 2013

Called GE service again, explained the broken pan and probed the service person a bit more about the pan breakage itself. It was an uncomfortable call. I was worried that GE might think that I'm breaking the water heater myself, either on purpose or by accident. The service person mentioned that they have had a lot of drain pan breaks with that model and that they are including a fitting with the pan. All new models now come with this fitting. It seems likely that this fitting will help reduce the chances that the pan breaks.

Images of the drain fitting setup and broken condensate pans


Drain pan attachment

One cracked drain pan

The 2nd cracked drain pan

Display panel showing 'FC' error code


The now well known 'FC' error code


Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Debugging an imprecise bus access fault on a Cortex-M3

This information may apply to other cortex series processors but is written from practical experience with the Cortex-M3. Imprecise bus access faults are ambiguous, as noted by the term "imprecise". Compared to precise bus errors, imprecise errors are much trickier to debug and especially so without a deep understanding of arm processors and assembly language. Imprecise and precise flags are found in the BusFault status register, a byte in the CFSR (Configurable Fault Status Register). BusFault status register bits The definition for imprecise and precise bits is: [2] IMPRECISERR Imprecise data bus error: 0 = no imprecise data bus error 1 = a data bus error has occurred, but the return address in the stack frame is not related to the instruction that caused the error. When the processor sets this bit to 1, it does not write a fault address to the BFAR. This is an asynchronous fault. Therefore, if it is detected when the priority of the current pr
5 comments
Read more

Graco Swing By Me - Battery to AC wall adapter modification

If you have one of these Graco battery powered swings you are probably familiar with the cost of C batteries! The swing takes four of them and they only last a handful of days. I'm not sure if the newer models support being plugged into the wall but ours didn't. If you are a little familiar with electronics and soldering, here is a rough guide on how you can modify yours to plug in! I wasn't sure how exactly to disassemble the swing side where the batteries were. I was able to open up the clamshell a bit but throughout this mod I was unable to determine how to fully separate the pieces. I suspect that there is some kind of a slip plate on the moving arm portion. The two parts of the plastic are assembled and the moving arm portion with the slip plate is slid onto the shaft. Because of the tension in that slip plate it doesn't want to back away, and because of the mechanicals that portion of the assembly doesn't appear accessible in order to free it. I was
Post a Comment
Read more

Memory efficient queuing of variable length elements

In embedded environments memory can be a critical driver of the design of data structures and containers. Computing resources have been expanding steadily each year but there are still a wide range of systems with far less than a megabyte of memory. On systems with tens of kilobytes of memory, structures are often designed to be compact to maximize data density. Rather than splurging on memory aligned elements that would be faster for the processor to access, a developer will typically use types with minimal sizes based on the known range of values that the element is intending to hold. Fixed sized buffers At my day job a fixed size pool of messages was implemented to hold message data. While this achieved one design goal of using statically allocated buffers, avoiding dynamic allocations that might fail at runtime, it isn't efficient if there is a wide range of message sizes. It isn't efficient because each message uses a message buffer. With small message sizes the buff
2 comments
Read more